Paul's daughter wants to be involved. Should I say yes?
Practice LibraryCoaching Scenario

Paul's daughter wants to be involved. Should I say yes?

~12 minutes
Manager
4 decisions
Intermediate
Quality Assurance & Improvement

What a Coaching Scenario is

Not quiz style. This is judgement practice — you're put inside a real situation from human-services work and asked what you would actually do. It draws on the knowledge you use on the job, not the kind you can look up.

Every choice changes what happens next, and every choice gets a coaching beat straight after it: what drew you toward that option, and how it played out. What's held back is the verdict on your path, so you stay with what you'd genuinely do rather than working out what you're supposed to say.

4 decisions
Each one shaped by the one before it. No two paths through are the same.
Coaching as you go
A beat after every decision, naming the pull behind your choice and where it led.
A full debrief
Your whole path replayed at the end, with the reasoning behind each decision you made.
Evidence you can keep
A completed scenario is recorded in your PracticeLab and appears in your downloadable ProofKit.

Scenarios are made to be talked about. Most people finish one still turning it over, which makes them a ready-made prompt for supervision, a team meeting or a conversation with a colleague — everyone walks the same situation, and comparing where you each landed is often where the real learning happens.

This one ends with

Before a family member asks to be involved in a complaint process, it's worth knowing in advance what your policy already says about that — so the answer comes from the framework, not from the pressure of the moment.

The situation

You manage a small community organisation that provides social support and activities for older adults. Earlier this week, Paul, an 84-year-old resident who attends your day programme three times a week, came to see you privately. He told you he'd been feeling upset and disrespected by a support worker, Tina, who he says has been dismissive of him in front of other residents. He spoke clearly and calmly — this is not the first time he's raised something with you, and you've always found him to be straightforward and reasonable.

You thanked Paul for coming to you and explained that you'd look into the matter carefully. You told him you'd be in touch about next steps. That afternoon, you wrote up a brief file note and began thinking about how to handle the complaint fairly — both for Paul and for Tina.

The next morning, you receive a call from Paul's daughter, Sione. She tells you her father came home upset last night and told the family what happened. She says the family is very concerned. She asks whether they can attend any meeting you hold to discuss the complaint — they want to make sure Paul is supported and that nothing gets swept under the rug. She's firm but polite, and you can hear genuine worry in her voice.

You're now sitting with a genuinely tricky situation. Family involvement matters in your organisation's values, and Sione's concern sounds real. But you're also aware that Tina deserves a fair process, that Paul's privacy belongs to him, and that you haven't yet confirmed what process you'll follow. You need to decide how to respond to Sione — and then work out how to proceed.


What you're practising

Procedural fairnessConfidentiality limitsDignity and respectFamily engagementDocumentationNatural justice

Before you start, notice

Real-world decisions in scenarios like this are shaped as much by feeling as by reasoning. People often notice one of these pulls — naming what you feel before you decide is half the skill.

  • The pull to accommodate — saying yes to the family feels warm, inclusive, and like good family engagement practice
  • Anxiety about Tina — wanting to protect her from what might feel like a loaded room
  • Unease about Paul — wondering whether you've already overstepped by talking to Sione at all
  • The urge to reassure Sione quickly, even before you know what you can actually promise

Policies this draws on

  • Your organisation's complaints and feedback policy
  • Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) / Privacy Act 2020 (NZ)
  • Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission Standards (AU) / Health and Disability Commissioner Act 1994 (NZ)
  • Your organisation's staff code of conduct
  • Your own organisation's policies take precedence — check them where they apply.

Heads up — coaching scenarios work differently. You'll make a sequence of decisions as the situation unfolds, and after each one you'll get a coaching beat: what drew you toward that choice, and how it played out. The one thing held back is the verdict on the path you took — that lands in the debrief at the end, with your whole walk replayed alongside it.

Sign in to begin

New to Good Practice Hub? Coaching Scenarios come with PracticeLab Pro, or browse the practice library to see what else is there.